One of Scotland Yard’s finest police officers, he is the officer that caught Aaron “Bow” Boden, the man who murdered Mr. Tannehill. Whenever the case is of importance, Officer McNaulty is called to the scene. While a good police officer, he can be bull-headed and pushy.

Office McNaulty has taken to trusting The Masked Bandit, regardless of the fact that most of the force believes that he is a criminal. He has been looking to the case to see what he can do to unravel the mystery. He would be willing to help The Masked Bandit in an unofficial capacity.